{
  "id": "https://www.moralclarity.ai/temporal-standing#property",
  "name": "Temporal Standing",
  "type": "defined_falsifiable_runtime_governance_property",
  "notation": "T₀ → ΔN → Tₙ",
  "definition": "Whether authority established for an exact consequence at T₀ still stands at Tₙ after relevant material or authoritative change ΔN.",
  "anti_inheritance_rule": "Prior validity does not automatically establish present authority for the exact consequence after relevant material change.",
  "states": [
    "PRESERVED",
    "DEFEATED",
    "UNRESOLVED"
  ],
  "protocol": {
    "name": "Temporal Standing Test",
    "url": "https://studio.moralclarity.ai/temporal-standing-test",
    "status": "published public falsification protocol"
  },
  "reference_implementation": {
    "name": "Harmonic",
    "url": "https://www.solace-harmonic.com/",
    "evidence_manifest": "https://www.solace-harmonic.com/evidence.json",
    "preserved_lineage": "https://www.solace-harmonic.com/preserved-examination-lineage.html",
    "implementation_evidence": {
      "classification": "first_party_bounded_implementation_evidence",
      "lineage_url": "https://www.solace-harmonic.com/preserved-examination-lineage.html",
      "records": [
        {
          "id": "SCGA-BS-003",
          "finding": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
          "preservation": "preserved failure",
          "scope": "Full discrimination was not established because the positive control was constitutionally incomplete; no rerun, repair, or remap."
        },
        {
          "id": "SCGA-BS-004",
          "finding": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
          "preservation": "preserved frozen-criterion failure",
          "scope": "Full counterfactual discrimination was not established because the frozen positive-control criterion required PERMITTED and observed CONSTRAINED/admissible=true/action=constrain."
        },
        {
          "id": "SCGA-BS-005",
          "finding": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_FROZEN_SCOPE",
          "preservation": "supported successor constituted prospectively",
          "scope": "In the examined native governed disposition path, historical validity did not silently retain consequential standing after one controlled material state transition invalidated the prior-state standing required for the same consequence."
        }
      ],
      "does_not_establish": [
        "downstream executor compliance or real-world consequence prevention",
        "omniscient detection of material conditions outside represented or observable state",
        "universal correctness across every domain, packet, consequence class, or possible ΔN",
        "architectural equivalence to another governance system",
        "that BS-003 or BS-004 passed"
      ]
    }
  },
  "evidence_boundary": "Protocol publication is not an examination result. Harmonic findings retain only the frozen implementation, path, boundary, conditions, and property actually examined. Findings do not automatically transfer to other MCAI systems or broader claims.",
  "organization": {
    "name": "Moral Clarity AI",
    "url": "https://www.moralclarity.ai/"
  },
  "canonical_url": "https://www.moralclarity.ai/temporal-standing",
  "updated_at": "2026-10-02",
  "external_examinations": {
    "registry_url": "https://www.moralclarity.ai/temporal-standing/examinations",
    "machine_readable": "https://www.moralclarity.ai/temporal-standing-examinations.json",
    "admission_rule": "Only publicly source-verifiable, independently attributable examinations are registered."
  }
}